Harry's Lightning Scar? SPOILERS?

Ok everyone whos read HP 7... I have a few logistical questions here.





1. How come Harry%26#039;s scar has disappeared during the Kings Cross scene, but 19 years later he has the scar again and touches it?


2. Seeing as Dumbledore is ashamed about his fixation on the Deathly Hallows, how come he willed the snitch, deluminator, and book to the kids?


3. When Harry survives Voldemort after thinking he%26#039;d die, is it due to Lily%26#039;s enchantment all those years ago, or simply due to his own bravery? Harry never actually became the master of death, so it must have been something else that helped him survive?

Harry%26#039;s Lightning Scar? SPOILERS?
1. The King%26#039;s Cross scene was all in Harry%26#039;s head. Whatever happened in there, stayed there. Kinda like Vegas.





2. Dumbledore wasn%26#039;t ashamed of his interests in the Hallows, but rather the methods he used to pursue that interest. He gave Harry, Ron, and Heirmoine the clues to the Hallows, but didn%26#039;t tell them about them, because he wanted them to mature to the point that they would use them properly, a point that it seemed only Harry really reached, as demonstrated by Ron%26#039;s ideas about getting rid of the wand at the end.





3.Harry survived the curse because Voldemort was still alive. When Voldy had used Harry%26#039;s blood as the catalyst for reforming his body, he transfered some of Harry%26#039;s protective spell into himself. Since Harry would still be protected by that spell as long as it lived on, as it did in Voldemort, the curse Voldemort used snuffed out the only unprotected part of Harry%26#039;s life, which just so happened to be the piece of Voldemort%26#039;s soul that Harry carried inside.





Hope i helped
Reply:good questions


1. It dissapered durring the kings cross scene because he was some kind of wierd thing between life and death. and i think his body was in like perfect conditon or something because he wasn%26#039; actually%26quot;there%26quot;( he also did not have glasses)


2. i think dumbledore wanted them to understand it before voldermort did. THe deluminator had nothing to do with the hallows.


3. Harry survived because the spell killed the part of voldermorts soul inside of him.
Reply:Because in the King%26#039;s Cross Harry was technically dead. And, it seemed when he was there, there were no burdens--like a scar. It%26#039;s like he starts over, in an afterlife. Notice he was naked as well, which is how your life usually begins. When he come back to life, all his problems return.


I think, at the time, Dumbledore didn%26#039;t realize he was ashamed until after death, which is why he gave them the snitch, book, and deluminator.


Harry%26#039;s bravery is what kept him alive, and the fact that he IS the master of death. He had all the Hallows.
Reply:1. it wasn%26#039;t really gone, that was like a dream, even though it was real, it%26#039;s like, the place you go to when you die, then the train brings you tocomplete death, i don%26#039;t know exactly how to explain it, but the dream thing is the best explanation i can think of :)


2. i guess because he knew them good enough to know that they would love to have those things and knew that they would use them right. the deluminator, he probably knew ron would need it, the book, they would all need it, but hermione is the only one who would want of use it. the ressurrection stone in the snitch, first, he knew harry would figure it out, and he knew he would want to see his parents %26quot;one last time%26quot;.


3. he was the 7th horcrux, voldemort killed the horcrux part of harry, that%26#039;s how harry survived, he himself was not killed, but the part of voldemort in harry was.
Reply:Hi!





1. It didn%26#039;t disappeared. He didn%26#039;t have in in the King Cross scene for the same reason he didn%26#039;t need his glasses... It was his spirit on that scene. When he comes back, the scar is still there





2. Well... death he couldn%26#039;t have done that much with them, right?!


He gave the things to the %26quot;kids%26quot; because they would help them to achieve what they had to achieve (the end of Voldemort) and because she trusted them to used them properly.


However, I get the impression that you seem to be a little mixed up. The deluminator and the book were not hallows... Just the stone contained in the snitch. The other hallos were the invisibility cloak (which was Harry%26#039;s) and the wand.


If you are not mixed up, do forgive me for clearing this! I just got confused by the writing!





3. No. What Voldemort killed actually was the bit of his own soul that lived inside Harry (remember that Harry was the 8th Horcrux... the one Voldemort didn%26#039;t know to have made). I guess that his bravery is what allowed him to go back after, because he had become, indeed the master of dead. And his bravery is what casted the protective spell upon those he was willing to die for.





What a great book, isn%26#039;t it?!





Goodluck!
Reply:Harry was the master of death. He owned the ring, the cloak, and although he didn%26#039;t know it at the time, he owned the wand as well. The same thing as the final scene and the wand backfired and killed Voldemort instead of his true master, well in the forrest, it killed Voldemort then too (the horcrux) and not Harry. I think Dumbledore wanted to give it to them so he could defeat Voldemort. The deluminator was because he knew Ron might run off and he was needed in the team for morale (on a jk interview) Harry had his scar, but in the kings cross chapter it was sort of like a perfect body thing, no scars, no black hands, what most people think that they will be like in heaven.
Reply:1. I really don%26#039;t know. Maybe it%26#039;s just the fact that Harry was %26quot;dead%26quot;. And everyone said that the scar would be gone at the end of the book, but they were wrong. Harry%26#039;s scar is not a cursed mark from Voldemort. It%26#039;s a mark of his mother%26#039;s love for him.





2. Dumbledore gave Harry the snitch so that the people he loved could be with him in his time of need and help him through his %26quot;death.%26quot; Dumbledore didn%26#039;t exactly know that Harry would live. It was just a guess. As for the book, Dumbledore wanted Harry to find out about the stone and the wand.





3. I think it was still due to Lily%26#039;s love for him.
Reply:1. It didn%26#039;t disappear. The King%26#039;s Cross chapter, as Dumbledore pointed out at the end, took place inside Harry%26#039;s head. Though it was %26quot;real%26quot;, it was a dream-like thing, an alternate reality if you will. His scar never actually disappeared - which is why it%26#039;s still there in the epilogue.


2. He knew they would need them to finish the task he%26#039;d set forth. He had to, in order to help them succeed. It didn%26#039;t make him any less ashamed though - he was happy when Harry told his portrait that the ring was dropped and forgotten, and the wand would not be used.


3. The enchantment placed upon him by Lily dying for him was in his blood. Therefore, when Voldemort used Harry%26#039;s blood to revive himself, it linked him as well - therefore, Harry could not die so long as Voldemort still lived (obviously, Voldemort did not know this, as we know he knows and cares nothing about love). Especially since Harry chose to make the same sacrifice Lily had all those years ago - the fact that he was willing to die for all those people is also what helped keeped him alive. It%26#039;s sort of hard to wrap your mind around.
Reply:1. How come Harry%26#039;s scar has disappeared during the Kings Cross scene, but 19 years later he has the scar again and touches it?


I didn%26#039;t even notice that he had lost his scar.3. When Harry survives Voldemort after thinking he%26#039;d die, is it due to Lily%26#039;s enchantment all those years ago, or simply due to his own bravery


Harry Survived because the Horcrox was the thing that was killed. Also because he accepted that he had to die to defeat Voldemort.Harry never actually became the master of death, so it must have been something else that helped him survive?


Harry I think is the master of death. He accepted that he had to die and he did. But then he found out that he only died to kill the Horcrox and once the Horcrox was killed be could come back to life!!!
Reply:1. The scar did not really disappear as it was Harry’s soul that was in the King’s Cross scene. In the same way he was not wearing his glasses but had no trouble seeing. His physical body was still lying on the forest floor where Voldemort had tried to kill him. Harry was actually at a point between life and death, as Dumbledore says, he could “board a train” or choose to return and try to finish what he started.





2. He willed the snitch to Harry because he realized that Harry was one of the one in a million people who had the power to reunite the Hallows. Dumbledore hid the ring in the Snitch with an enchantment that only allowed it to open when Harry decided to let Voldemort kill him. This allowed him to bring back the souls of his parents, Lupin and Sirius which protected him from the Dementors as they were a “living” patronus. Dumbledore also knew how intelligent Hermoine was and how cautious. The book contained hints to the Deathly Hallows which Harry needed to learn about in order to defeat Voldemort. Hermoine’s natural caution prevented Harry from rushing off too fast and allowed him to finish performing the tasks he was supposed to complete. He left Ron the deluminator as, as Harry said, he knew that Ron would always come back to them. The deluminator had more than the power to absorb or release light, it also acted as a special type of port key and a locator that Ron could use to find and go to Harry and Hermoine.





3. As Dumbledore states, when Voldemort used Harry’s blood to restore his own body, he transferred part of Lily’s enchantment into his own body. Since the enchantment was protection for Harry, as long as Voldemort was still alive, he could not actually kill Harry since the enchantment was still working. If you remember in the “Goblet of Fire”, Dumbledore’s eyes glowed for a minute when he heard the Voldemort had used Harry’s blood. He realized at this point that Harry had a chance of defeating Voldemort and surviving. Prior to this the defeat of Voldemort would have required Harry to sacrifice is life. Harry did become the “Master of Death”. Harry became it when he offered his life to save his friends, the true master of death is one who is not afraid of it and willing to face it to save others.
Reply:1.The same way Dumbledore%26#039;s hand wasn%26#039;t burned.


2.He knew he was about to die, and he thought the Hallows might help Harry defeat Voldemort.


3.I think it was the fact that Harry wanted to die, and because Voldemort killed his own Horcrux. Lily%26#039;s enchantment helped too. And he possessed all three deathly hallows, so I think he was after all, Master of Death.
Reply:Because at the King%26#039;s Cross, he is in Heaven within his own mind, and everything appears perfect.





He willed the Resurrection Stone to Harry knowing that he would have to die in the end, and by that time that he would understand truths about how dangerous the Hallows could be. That one is a bit hard to explain, but it%26#039;s all in my head.





He walked straight into Death%26#039;s arms, instead of running from or fearing it.








I hope these answers made sense to you, it%26#039;s a bit hard trying to explain them when I can%26#039;t concentrate. (Noisy parents) :·]
Reply:harry is weird
Reply:this is so boring......



dental